Search blog.co.uk

Mankind needs to be grounded

by hf148 @ 07.05.2007 - 18:53:17

Max Hastings has written on Comment is Free that our “binge- flying” culture must end because of the disastrous effects it will have on the environment. This is indeed a big problem. Air travel is becoming steadily cheaper, and traveling long-distance to far-flung exotic destinations is ever more popular. Developing countries rely on tourism and exporting goods via the air to support their growing economies, and flying at the weekends is perfectly normal for many people in need of a quick change of scene.  
Max Hasting’s argues that the best solution to this is a tax on aviation fuel, upping the price of flights drastically. Suggestions have also been made to ban “budget” travelers, who holiday cheaply and explore off the beaten track.
 This is an unfair solution- the rich will continue to fly and pollute as they have always done, whilst the rest of the world will be closed to poorer tourists. Money will be a determining factor not only in education and life expectancy, but also the right to leave these shores to experience new cultures- even if people can only afford to go across the Channel to France or to the Costa Del Sol 

However, if flights are not restricted through fiscal means, what then to curb the aviation industry’s growing emissions?
Firstly, airport expansion should end. The industry cannot expand any more if we are to tackle climate change. There is just no room for this vastly polluting sector’s increasing emissions. Secondly, flights must always be full. Flying two half empty planes to the same destination within hours of each other is farcical.  
Thirdly, whilst I would not advocate pricing people out of tourism, perhaps we should consider flying quotas- restrictions on the number of air miles that people can travel in one year. Countries should be given, depending on population, size and other factors, a binding target on overall emissions, which they cannot exceed. Individual governments could determine what proportion of overall emissions could come from aviation and ration air miles accordingly. The countries with the lowest amount of emissions from other sectors could therefore be more generous with air miles. Thus there would be an incentive for countries to use renewable energy and electric cars, for example, so a bigger proportion of emissions could be allocated to aviation.  Modern technology negates the need for flying in business- meetings can be conducted via web cams and conference calls. The same applies for politics. Wealthier people could still take their regular holidays, but once they had used their quota they would have to take alternative transport- using trains, coaches and boats. We have the Eurostar and there is an excellent train system over on the continent- therefore exploring Europe without air travel is perfectly feasible, and perhaps much more enjoyable as one gets to interact with the journey far more. For further afield journeys, there is the Orient Express, traversing Russia and China. Expanding the shipping industry, and coming up with fairly fast and efficient ships would make crossing the Atlantic not-impossible if one has used up all of ones air miles.  
Fourthly, offsetting carbon emissions, whilst not an answer to all ills, should become the norm for everyone traveling abroad. Finally, there must be more money spent on researching ways to improve the carbon emissions of planes. If they can be made much more environmentally friendly, then the above restrictions need not be so stringent.  

Humans have survived for thousands of years, and explored the world, without airplanes before. We can do it again.


 
 

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

Irish-Le-FeauxIrish-Le-Feaux [Member]
2007-05-07 @ 19:33

Which is all very well if you are a believer in the carbon footprint, global warming being down to human activity story. Personally I think that this is more down to solar activity and natural warming than to human activity.

Our climate has changed continuously over millions of years and continues to do so. Stopping people fliying away on holiday is not going to change that.

sallyontoursallyontour pro
2007-05-08 @ 11:04

I have not fallen for the carbon footprint ploy either. Nor will I stop flying. Humans have indeed explored the world before air travel, but note they were mostly wealthy and privileged humans. Is this a cunning plan to once again restrict travel to the rich and powerful, and furthermore keep the Third World in its place?

If previous history is anything to go by, the Earth is long overdue for (natural) cataclysmic climate change, and if that means curtains for the human race then I say give the cockroaches a chance. They can't b****r it up any more than we have!

With that logic, stopping people flying away on holiday may not stop climate change then, but it will still lessen air pollution and noise pollution. Whilst people have the right to make their own informed decisions about whether or not they believe in climate change, that doesn't mean mankind can continue to pollute the way it does. You may not think that it will have an affect on the climate, fair enough, but surely you don't want a world filled with used disposable nappies and an ocean filled with plastic bags??

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Recent Posts

  1. Shame on Moscow
    by hf148 on 28.05.2007
  2. For the missing
    by hf148 on 28.05.2007
  3. Images of death
    by hf148 on 28.05.2007
  4. Olympic fears
    by hf148 on 13.05.2007
  5. Poor Lord Browne
    by hf148 on 05.05.2007
  6. I can't save the world- my toilet roll is rubbish
    by hf148 on 29.04.2007
  7. Consumerism gone Mad!!
    by hf148 on 28.04.2007
  8. Why I love Miliband
    by hf148 on 27.04.2007
  9. Should I kill him??
    by hf148 on 27.04.2007
  10. Welcome to the world
    by hf148 on 24.04.2007

Footer

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.